Skip navigation
FACT
Focus on Alternative and Complementary Therapies

Silybum marianum (milk thistle) and indinavir: an RCT and meta-analysis

Mills E1, Wilson K2, Foster B3, Phillips E4, Walker S4, Rachlis B1, Montori VM5, Myers SP6, Clarke M7, Gallicano S8
1Canadian College of Naturopathic Medicine
2Department of Medicine, University of Toronto, Canada
3Therapeutic Products Directorate, Health, Canada
4Sunnybrooke & Women’s College Hospital, Toronto, Canada
5Department of Medicine, Mayo Clinic, USA
6Australian Centre for Complementary Medicine, Education & Research, University of Queensland, Australia
7UK Cochrane Centre
8Watson Laboratories, USA

Objective

To determine if ingestion of Silybum marianum (milk thistle) affects the pharmacokinetics of indinavir, the authors conducted a three-period, RCT with 16 healthy participants.

Materials and methods

Participants were randomised participants to S. marianum or control. All participants received initial dosing of indinavir and baseline indinavir levels were obtained (AUC0–8) (Phase I). The active group then were given 450 mg S. marianum extract capsules to be taken tid from day 2 to day 30. On days 29 and 30, indinavir dosing and sampling was repeated in both groups as before (Phase II). After a washout period of 7 days, indinavir dosing and sampling were repeated as before (Phase III).

Results

Active group mean AUC0–8 indinavir reduced by –4.4% (90% CI, –27.5 to 26%, P = 0.78) from Phase I to Phase II in the active group and by –17.3% (90% CI, –37.3 to 9%, P = 0.25) in Phase III. Control group mean AUC0–8 reduced by –21.5% (90% CI, –43 to 8%, P = 0.2) from Phase I to Phase II and by a significant further reduction at Phase III of –38.5% (90% CI, –55.3 to –15.3%, P = 0.01) of baseline. Indinavir levels were not reduced significantly in the presence of S. marianum.

Conclusion

The significant decline of AUC0–8 in the control group indicates that factors other than the exposure of interest may affect drug pharmacokinetics. To place our findings in context, S. marianum–indinavir trials were identified through systematic searches of the literature. A meta-analysis of three S. marianum–indinavir trials revealed a non-significant pooled mean difference of 1% (95% CI, 53 to 55%, P = 0.97).

Acknowledgement

Funded by the Ontario HIV Treatment Network.

Top | Next: Experiencing Reiki treatments: patients’ and practitioners’ perspectives»
© Pharmaceutical Press 2009
Accessibility | Terms and Conditions